top of page

Mastering the Art of Talent Selection: 10 Proven Strategies to Test and Evaluate Candidates

Hiring the right talent is crucial for the success of any organization. The process of evaluating candidates prior to making a hiring decision has evolved over time, and research suggests that a combination of different assessment methods yields the most effective results. In this article, we will explore ten essential methods to test and inspect talent prior to hiring, providing valuable insights into their benefits and applications.

Work Samples

Work samples are a valuable tool for assessing a candidate's skills and abilities in a practical manner. By requiring candidates to produce a product or perform a task relevant to the job, employers can evaluate their capabilities firsthand. Work samples provide tangible evidence of a candidate's potential, allowing employers to gauge their suitability for the role.

While traditional work samples often focus on specific tasks or projects directly related to the job, there are certain types of work samples that may not be commonly asked for but can provide valuable insights into a candidate's abilities and potential. Here are a few examples:

  • Problem-solving scenarios: Presenting candidates with hypothetical problem-solving scenarios allows them to demonstrate their critical thinking skills and their ability to analyze and solve complex challenges. This type of work sample can be particularly useful for positions that require strong problem-solving abilities, strategic thinking, and decision-making skills.

  • Creativity and innovation: For roles that demand creativity and innovation, requesting work samples that showcase a candidate's ability to think outside the box can be valuable. This could include examples of creative projects, design portfolios, or innovative solutions they have developed in the past. By evaluating a candidate's creative output, employers can gain insights into their ability to generate fresh ideas and contribute to innovative initiatives.

  • Communication samples: Strong communication skills are vital in many job roles. While interviews provide some insight into a candidate's communication abilities, requesting specific communication samples can offer a more comprehensive evaluation. This could involve asking for written samples, such as reports, articles, or presentations, or even requesting recorded presentations or public speaking samples. Assessing a candidate's ability to articulate ideas clearly, persuasively, and effectively is crucial for roles that involve client interactions, leadership, or public speaking.

  • Team collaboration: Collaboration and teamwork are increasingly important in the modern workplace. To gauge a candidate's ability to work effectively within a team, employers can ask for work samples that showcase their collaborative skills. This could include examples of group projects, team presentations, or reports that demonstrate the candidate's ability to contribute to a collective effort, communicate and coordinate with team members, and achieve shared goals.

  • Adaptability and learning: In today's rapidly evolving work environment, adaptability and a willingness to learn are highly valued traits. Requesting work samples that highlight a candidate's adaptability and ability to acquire new skills can be beneficial. This could involve evidence of successfully navigating challenging situations, taking on new responsibilities, or participating in training programs. Assessing a candidate's adaptability and learning potential can be particularly relevant for roles that require continuous growth and adaptability to changing circumstances.

Cognitive Ability Tests

Cognitive ability tests assess a candidate's critical thinking skills, problem-solving abilities, and capacity to learn new information. These tests provide objective measurements of a candidate's intellectual aptitude, helping employers identify individuals with the mental agility required to excel in the job. Here are some commonly used cognitive ability tests:

  • The Wonderlic Personnel Test is a widely recognized cognitive ability test used for pre-employment screening. It assesses an individual's problem-solving skills, critical thinking, and general cognitive abilities. The test consists of multiple-choice questions with a time limit.

  • The Watson-Glaser Critical Thinking Appraisal is a popular assessment tool that measures an individual's ability to analyze and make decisions based on critical thinking skills. It evaluates a candidate's skills in areas such as inference, deduction, interpretation, and evaluation.

  • Raven's Progressive Matrices is a non-verbal test that assesses abstract reasoning and problem-solving abilities. It presents candidates with visual patterns and requires them to identify the missing element or complete the pattern. Raven's Progressive Matrices is often used to evaluate individuals' fluid intelligence.

  • CogAT (Cognitive Abilities Test) is a cognitive abilities test commonly used in educational and employment settings. It measures an individual's reasoning abilities in areas such as verbal, quantitative, and non-verbal reasoning. The test is particularly useful for assessing cognitive potential in academic or intellectually demanding environments.

Behavioral Interviews

Behavioral interviews delve into a candidate's past experiences and behaviors to assess their suitability for a particular role. By asking specific questions about real-life scenarios, employers gain insights into how candidates have handled similar situations in the past. This method helps identify candidates who possess the desired competencies and align with the company's values. While there are common behavioral interview questions, incorporating less frequently asked questions can provide additional insights into a candidate's suitability for the role. Here are some questions that are not commonly asked but can be valuable in behavioral interviews:

  • Tell me about a time when you faced a major setback or failure in your career. How did you handle it, and what did you learn from the experience? This question explores a candidate's resilience, ability to overcome challenges, and their approach to learning from setbacks. It provides insights into their problem-solving skills, adaptability, and growth mindset.

  • Describe a situation where you had to work with a difficult colleague or team member. How did you handle the situation, and what was the outcome? This question assesses a candidate's interpersonal skills, conflict resolution abilities, and their ability to collaborate effectively in challenging situations. It sheds light on their communication style, problem-solving strategies, and their attitude towards teamwork.

  • Can you share an example of a time when you had to make a difficult decision that went against popular opinion or faced resistance? How did you navigate through it, and what were the results? This question evaluates a candidate's decision-making abilities, critical thinking, and their ability to stand by their convictions. It provides insights into their leadership potential, ability to handle tough choices, and their ability to influence others.

  • Tell me about a time when you identified an opportunity for process improvement or innovation in your previous role. How did you approach it, and what impact did it have? This question assesses a candidate's initiative, problem-solving skills, and their ability to contribute to organizational growth. It helps evaluate their ability to think strategically, identify opportunities for improvement, and drive positive change.

  • Describe a situation where you had to deliver difficult feedback or handle a sensitive conversation with a coworker or team member. How did you approach it, and what was the outcome? This question examines a candidate's communication skills, emotional intelligence, and their ability to handle challenging conversations. It provides insights into their diplomacy, empathy, and their approach to resolving conflicts in the workplace.

  • Can you share an example of a time when you took the initiative to develop new skills or acquire additional knowledge outside of your job requirements? How did it contribute to your professional growth? This question explores a candidate's proactiveness, motivation for self-improvement, and their commitment to continuous learning. It helps assess their drive for personal and professional development and their ability to adapt to evolving job demands.

Skills Tests

Skills tests evaluate a candidate's proficiency in specific skills and abilities directly related to the job. These tests can be tailored to assess technical expertise, language proficiency, or any other specific skill set required for the role. Skills tests offer employers an accurate measurement of a candidate's capabilities, enabling them to make informed hiring decisions. When hiring for any position, there are several common skills tests that can help assess a candidate's abilities and suitability for the role. These tests can provide valuable insights into their skills, knowledge, and potential for success. Here are some commonly used skills tests that can be applied across various positions.

  • Communication Skills: Assess a candidate's written and verbal communication abilities by asking them to complete a writing exercise, deliver a presentation, or engage in a mock conversation or role-play. This test evaluates their clarity, organization, articulation, and ability to convey ideas effectively.

  • Problem-Solving and Critical Thinking: Present candidates with real or hypothetical problems and ask them to provide solutions or walk through their thought process. This test evaluates their analytical skills, ability to think critically, and approach to problem-solving.

  • Technical Skills: If the position requires specific technical expertise, administer a skills test related to those technical skills. For example, coding tests for software developers, Excel proficiency tests for data analysts, or design tasks for graphic designers. This test assesses their proficiency in the required technical skills.

  • Attention to Detail: Present candidates with tasks that require careful attention to detail, such as proofreading a document, identifying errors in data sets, or completing a task with specific instructions. This test evaluates their accuracy, thoroughness, and ability to spot and correct errors.

  • Time Management and Prioritization: Simulate a scenario where candidates need to manage multiple tasks with competing deadlines. This could involve asking them to create a schedule or prioritize a list of tasks based on urgency and importance. This test assesses their ability to manage time effectively, prioritize tasks, and meet deadlines.

Psychological Tests

Psychological tests can identify potential work-related levels of stress, anxiety, or other psychological issues that may impact job performance. Psychological tests help employers ensure a healthy and productive work environment. When contemplating psychological tests, it is crucial to acknowledge that these assessments should not be utilized as part of the hiring process. However, they serve as valuable tools for comprehending individuals in contexts such as EAP (Employee Assistance Program), one-on-one coaching or counseling, team development, and more. To guarantee proper administration, it is essential to have qualified professionals administer the tests and adhere to ethical guidelines.

Here are some commonly used psychological tests in the hiring process:

  • Emotional Intelligence (EI) Assessments: EI assessments measure a candidate's ability to understand, manage, and express emotions effectively. These tests evaluate competencies such as self-awareness, self-regulation, empathy, and relationship management. Assessing emotional intelligence can be particularly relevant for roles that require strong interpersonal skills, leadership, or client/customer interaction. The most reliable Emotional Intelligence test is EQi2.0 which evaluates various aspects of emotional intelligence, including self-awareness, self-expression, interpersonal skills, decision-making, and stress management. However, as mentioned above, this assessment is not to be used in the hiring process.

  • Cognitive and Mental Ability Tests: Cognitive and mental ability tests assess a candidate's cognitive capabilities, such as problem-solving, critical thinking, memory, and logical reasoning. These tests help evaluate a candidate's intellectual potential and their ability to handle complex tasks and learn new information. Examples of cognitive ability tests include the Wechsler Adult Intelligence Scale (WAIS) and the Raven's Progressive Matrices.

  • Behavioral and Situational Judgment Tests (SJTs): Behavioral assessments and SJTs present candidates with real-life scenarios or work-related situations and ask them to choose the most appropriate response or rank different options based on their judgment. These tests assess a candidate's decision-making skills, ethical reasoning, and ability to navigate challenging situations effectively.

  • Stress and Resilience Assessments: Stress and resilience assessments evaluate a candidate's ability to cope with stress, handle pressure, and bounce back from setbacks. These tests can help identify individuals who are better equipped to handle high-stress environments or roles that involve frequent change or demanding situations.

  • Motivational and Values Assessments: Motivational and values assessments explore a candidate's core values, motivations, and career aspirations. These tests can help determine if a candidate's values align with the organization's culture and if they are genuinely motivated to succeed in the role.

Prior to implementing any of the aforementioned tests, it is advisable to consult with a local HR law advisor to assess their appropriateness for the position within your jurisdiction. It is important to note that testing requirements can differ by state, hence seeking guidance will ensure compliance with relevant regulations.

Personality Tests

Personality tests measure a candidate's behavioral tendencies, attitudes, and values. By evaluating personality traits, employers can determine how well a candidate would fit within the team and the company culture. Personality tests assist in building a cohesive and harmonious workforce by identifying individuals with compatible dispositions. During the hiring process, there are various types of personality tests that you can consider administering to gain insights into a candidate's behavioral tendencies, attitudes, and values. Here are some commonly used personality tests.

  • Myers-Briggs Type Indicator (MBTI): The MBTI is one of the most widely known and used personality assessments. It categorizes individuals into different personality types based on four dimensions: extraversion/introversion, sensing/intuition, thinking/feeling, and judging/perceiving. The MBTI provides insights into a candidate's preferences, communication style, and decision-making approach.

  • Big Five Personality Traits Assessment: The Big Five personality traits assessment measures five key dimensions of personality: openness to experience, conscientiousness, extraversion, agreeableness, and emotional stability (neuroticism). This assessment provides a comprehensive understanding of a candidate's personality profile and can help predict behavior in various work-related situations.

  • DISC Assessment: The DISC assessment categorizes individuals into four behavioral styles: dominance, influence, steadiness, and conscientiousness. This assessment helps identify a candidate's dominant behavioral style and provides insights into their communication preferences, work motivations, and team dynamics.

  • Hogan Personality Inventory (HPI): The HPI assesses a candidate's personality traits related to work performance and leadership potential. It provides insights into key aspects such as interpersonal effectiveness, ambition, self-confidence, and sociability. The HPI can help predict a candidate's fit within a specific organizational culture and their potential for success in leadership roles.

  • Enneagram: The Enneagram is a personality system that categorizes individuals into nine distinct personality types, each with unique motivations, fears, and behavioral patterns. The Enneagram can offer insights into a candidate's core motivations, stress responses, and interpersonal dynamics.

  • StrengthsFinder: The StrengthsFinder assessment identifies an individual's strengths and talents across 34 different themes. This assessment focuses on understanding a candidate's natural abilities and can help identify areas where they are likely to excel and contribute most effectively.

Integrity Tests

Integrity tests evaluate a candidate's honesty and trustworthiness. These tests are particularly important for positions that involve handling sensitive information, finances, or maintaining a position of trust. By assessing a candidate's integrity, employers can mitigate the risk of hiring individuals with questionable ethics. Here are some examples of integrity tests that you can consider incorporating into the hiring process.

  • Behavioral-based Integrity Questions: During interviews, ask candidates specific questions about ethical dilemmas they may have faced in the past, how they handled those situations, and what values guided their decisions. This helps evaluate their integrity, moral reasoning, and their ability to make ethical choices.

  • Situational Judgment Tests (SJTs): Administer SJTs that present candidates with hypothetical scenarios related to integrity and ethics. Ask them to rank or choose the most appropriate course of action. This test assesses their ethical decision-making skills, judgment, and alignment with the organization's values.

  • References and Background Checks: Conduct thorough reference checks to verify a candidate's integrity and honesty. Contact their previous employers or colleagues to gain insights into their work ethics, trustworthiness, and adherence to ethical standards.

  • Cognitive Ability Tests: Incorporate cognitive ability tests that include items related to ethical decision-making and integrity. These tests can evaluate a candidate's ability to recognize ethical dilemmas, analyze the consequences of different choices, and make ethical judgments.

  • Self-Reported Integrity Questionnaires: Use self-report questionnaires that ask candidates to rate their own behaviors, attitudes, and values related to integrity. These questionnaires can help identify candidates who are self-aware and have a strong sense of personal and professional ethics.

  • Scenarios Assessing Confidentiality: Present candidates with scenarios that involve confidential information, trade secrets, or sensitive data. Evaluate their understanding of the importance of confidentiality and their willingness to abide by non-disclosure agreements and protect sensitive information.

Physical Ability Tests

Physical ability tests assess a candidate's physical capabilities and fitness for specific job requirements. These tests are commonly used in physically demanding roles, such as those in construction, healthcare, or law enforcement. Ensuring candidates possess the necessary physical abilities promotes safety and reduces the likelihood of on-the-job injuries.

Before administering a physical ability test during the hiring process, it's important to consider several factors to ensure fairness, safety, and compliance with legal and ethical guidelines. Here are some key considerations. By considering these factors, you can administer a physical ability test that is job-relevant, fair, safe, and compliant with legal and ethical standards. It's important to approach physical ability testing with a focus on equal opportunity, inclusivity, and candidate well-being.

  • Job Relevance: Evaluate the relevance of the physical ability test to the specific job requirements. Determine if physical abilities, such as strength, stamina, flexibility, or coordination, are critical for performing the essential functions of the job. The test should directly assess the candidate's capability to perform the necessary physical tasks.

  • Legal Compliance: Ensure that the physical ability test complies with all applicable laws, regulations, and guidelines. Familiarize yourself with local labor laws, disability accommodation requirements, and equal opportunity regulations to ensure that the test does not discriminate against protected groups or individuals with disabilities.

  • Validity and Reliability: Select or develop a physical ability test that has been validated and demonstrated to be reliable. The test should accurately measure the specific physical abilities it aims to assess. Consider consulting with experts or reputable test providers to ensure the validity and reliability of the test.

  • Safety Measures: Prioritize candidate safety by implementing appropriate safety measures during the physical ability test. Clearly communicate any potential risks associated with the test and ensure that the test environment is safe and conducive to physical activities. Provide proper equipment, supervision, and guidelines to minimize the risk of injuries.

  • Reasonable Accommodations: Consider providing reasonable accommodations for candidates with disabilities or medical conditions, as required by law. Engage in an interactive dialogue with candidates to determine if any accommodations are needed to enable their participation in the physical ability test. Accommodations should be provided unless they create undue hardship or fundamentally alter the nature of the job.

  • Consistency and Standardization: Administer the physical ability test consistently and uniformly to all candidates to ensure fairness and avoid bias. Follow standardized protocols, scoring criteria, and instructions to maintain consistency across candidates.

  • Communication and Informed Consent: Clearly communicate the purpose, expectations, and requirements of the physical ability test to candidates in advance. Obtain their informed consent to participate and provide them with an opportunity to ask questions or raise concerns. Transparency and open communication help establish a fair and positive testing experience.

  • Professional Guidance: Consider seeking guidance from experts, occupational therapists, or professionals with experience in physical ability testing. They can provide valuable insights, help select appropriate tests, and ensure compliance with best practices.

Job-Related Simulations

Job-related simulations allow candidates to demonstrate their skills and abilities in realistic scenarios closely resembling the actual job. These simulations can take the form of case studies, role-playing exercises, or other interactive assessments. Job-related simulations provide valuable insights into a candidate's performance, decision-making, and problem-solving abilities. Here are some under-rated job-related simulations you may consider incorporating into the hiring process.

  • Role Play with Realistic Scenarios: Utilize role-playing exercises with realistic workplace scenarios relevant to the job. For example, simulate a customer service interaction, a team conflict resolution, or a sales pitch. This allows candidates to demonstrate their communication skills, problem-solving abilities, and their approach to handling real-time situations.

  • In-Basket Exercises: In-basket exercises present candidates with a simulated inbox containing various tasks, emails, memos, and documents that reflect the typical workload and responsibilities of the position. Candidates must prioritize tasks, make decisions, and demonstrate organizational and time management skills.

  • Business Simulation Games: Introduce candidates to business simulation games that simulate real-world business situations, such as managing a virtual company, making strategic decisions, and navigating market dynamics. These simulations provide insights into candidates' strategic thinking, decision-making, and ability to analyze complex business scenarios.

  • Virtual Reality (VR) Simulations: VR simulations create immersive experiences that replicate job-specific environments. For example, in the healthcare industry, VR simulations can simulate surgical procedures, allowing candidates to demonstrate their technical skills and decision-making under realistic conditions. VR simulations can also be used in fields like manufacturing, aviation, or emergency response to assess skills and reactions.

  • Group Problem-Solving Activities: Conduct group problem-solving activities that require candidates to collaborate and work as a team to solve complex challenges. These activities can involve brainstorming sessions, group projects, or problem-solving scenarios. They help assess candidates' teamwork, communication, and leadership skills in a collaborative setting.

  • Presentation or Project Demonstration: Ask candidates to prepare and deliver a presentation or demonstrate a project related to the job. This allows them to showcase their skills, knowledge, and ability to present information effectively. It assesses their communication skills, subject matter expertise, and their ability to engage and persuade an audience.

Drug and Alcohol Tests

Drug and alcohol tests determine if a candidate has any substances in their system that could impair their ability to perform their job safely and effectively. These tests are particularly important for safety-sensitive roles, as they help ensure a secure work environment and reduce the risks associated with substance abuse.

Administering a drug and alcohol test during the hiring process requires careful consideration to ensure compliance with legal requirements, maintain candidate privacy, and promote fairness. Here are some guidelines on how to effectively administer a drug and alcohol test.

  • Establish a Clear Policy: Develop a clear and comprehensive drug and alcohol testing policy that outlines the purpose of testing, the substances being tested for, the testing methods employed, and the consequences of positive results. Make sure the policy complies with local laws, regulations, and industry standards.

  • Obtain Consent and Inform Candidates: Before conducting drug and alcohol testing, inform candidates about the testing process, its purpose, and their rights and responsibilities. Obtain written consent from candidates, ensuring they understand the policy and their rights regarding confidentiality and the handling of test results.

  • Select Appropriate Testing Methods: Choose the appropriate testing method based on the specific requirements of your organization and the role. Common drug and alcohol testing methods include urine tests, breath tests, blood tests, or hair follicle tests. Each method has its own benefits and limitations, so consider factors such as cost, accuracy, and detection periods when selecting the method.

  • Engage a Certified Testing Provider: Partner with a certified testing provider or laboratory that adheres to professional standards and has experience in administering drug and alcohol tests. Ensure they follow strict protocols for sample collection, handling, testing, and maintaining the confidentiality of results.

  • Schedule and Conduct Testing: Schedule drug and alcohol testing for candidates who have progressed through the hiring process and are nearing the final stages. Provide clear instructions to candidates regarding the testing location, date, and time. Ensure the testing environment is private, secure, and conducive to maintaining candidate confidentiality.

  • Maintain Chain of Custody: Maintain a strict chain of custody throughout the testing process to ensure the integrity and validity of the test results. Document the collection, labeling, transportation, and storage of samples to prevent tampering or contamination.

  • Respect Candidate Privacy and Confidentiality: Handle test results and related information with utmost confidentiality. Only authorized personnel involved in the hiring process should have access to the results. Follow legal requirements regarding the storage and retention of test results, and ensure compliance with privacy laws.

  • Communicate Results and Follow-Up: Once the results are available, communicate them to candidates in a professional and sensitive manner. If a candidate tests positive, follow the procedures outlined in your drug and alcohol testing policy, which may include further verification, counseling, or withdrawal of the job offer based on the results.

The main takeaway

Testing and inspecting talent prior to making hiring decisions is an essential practice that can significantly impact the success of your organization. By incorporating a combination of assessment methods, including job-related simulations, behavioral interviews, and cognitive ability tests, you can gain comprehensive insights into a candidate's skills, abilities, and potential fit within your company culture. Involving current employees in the hiring process through employee referral programs or panel interviews can also contribute to a more accurate assessment of a candidate's suitability for the team.

Implementing integrity tests, skills tests, and physical ability tests where applicable can provide valuable information to inform your hiring decisions. It is crucial to design and administer these tests in a manner that aligns with the specific job requirements, complies with legal and ethical standards, and ensures fairness and confidentiality for all candidates.

By adopting these ten effective methods to test and inspect talent, you can optimize your hiring process and increase the likelihood of selecting candidates who will thrive within your organization, contributing to its long-term success.

Copyright © 2023 by Arete Coach LLC. All rights reserved.


bottom of page