top of page

Considerations for CEOs: Terminating an Employee for Cause to Safeguard Company Interests

When it comes to safeguarding your company's interests, terminating an employee for cause demands careful consideration. Such a decision should not be taken lightly, as it carries significant implications for your organization. As a CEO, it is imperative that you approach this situation with utmost caution to mitigate potential risks. To navigate the complex situation, it is advisable to seek guidance from your Human Resource Attorney and involve your HR department manager. Their expertise will prove invaluable in ensuring a seamless and legally sound course of action.

An image created using MidJourney, 6/7/23

Causes for termination

There are several circumstances where terminating an employee becomes necessary to shield your company from harm. By identifying these situations, you can proactively address potential risks and safeguard your organization's well-being. Let's explore some scenarios where termination for cause may be warranted.

  1. Gross misconduct: If an employee engages in serious misconduct, such as theft, fraud, violence, harassment, or violation of company policies, termination may be necessary to protect the safety and well-being of other employees, maintain a positive work environment, and safeguard the company's reputation.

  2. Breach of confidentiality: If an employee discloses sensitive or confidential information to unauthorized individuals, it can have detrimental effects on the company, including loss of competitive advantage, damage to client relationships, or compromising proprietary information. Termination may be necessary to prevent further harm.

  3. Negligence or incompetence: If an employee consistently performs their job poorly, fails to meet performance standards, or displays a lack of competence that can potentially harm the company's operations, reputation, or financial stability, termination may be necessary to maintain the company's overall effectiveness and success.

  4. Violation of legal or regulatory requirements: If an employee engages in illegal activities, violates regulations, or fails to comply with laws relevant to the company's industry, termination may be required to protect the company from potential legal consequences, fines, penalties, or damage to its professional standing.

  5. Breach of trust: If an employee betrays the trust of the company or their colleagues, such as through embezzlement, unauthorized disclosure of sensitive information, or deliberate sabotage, termination may be necessary to preserve the integrity of the organization and prevent further harm.

Considerations when terminating an employee

It's important to note that the decision to terminate an employee should be based on substantial evidence, following proper procedures and legal requirements. Consulting with an HR attorney and involving the HR department in the decision-making process can help ensure compliance with applicable laws and minimize potential legal risks for the company. Here are ten ways a CEO can minimize the potential negative impacts when terminating an employee for cause:

  1. Conduct a thorough investigation before making a decision to terminate. When conducting an investigation before making the decision to terminate an employee, it is crucial to follow a systematic approach. Begin by planning the investigation, clearly defining the objectives and identifying the specific allegations. Preserve evidence securely and maintain confidentiality throughout the process. Interview the relevant parties, including the employee under investigation and any witnesses, while keeping detailed notes. Review documentation and analyze the findings objectively, considering all relevant information. Seek guidance from HR professionals and legal counsel to ensure compliance with employment laws. Based on the investigation findings, make an informed decision regarding termination or alternative disciplinary measures, following proper procedures and providing a clear explanation to the employee if termination is chosen. Consulting with legal professionals is essential to ensure compliance and minimize potential risks.

  2. Communicate openly and honestly with the employee. When having a termination conversation with an employee, it is important to approach it with empathy and professionalism. Choose a private setting, prepare by reviewing relevant documentation, and communicate openly and honestly. Clearly state the purpose of the meeting, provide specific reasons for the termination using objective language and supporting evidence, and allow the employee to respond. Offer support and assistance based on company policies, discuss confidentiality, and end the conversation respectfully, expressing gratitude and a desire for their future success. Consulting with HR professionals or legal counsel is advisable to ensure compliance and navigate any unique circumstances.

  3. Provide the employee with an opportunity to respond. To provide the employee with an opportunity to respond to allegations and present their side of the story, schedule a separate meeting before the termination meeting. Share the concerns and allegations in writing, create an open environment for dialogue, actively listen to their perspective, ask clarifying questions, and document their responses. Evaluate their input and determine if it impacts the termination decision. If not, proceed with the termination meeting, clearly communicating the reasons while acknowledging the employee's viewpoint expressed earlier. This approach ensures fairness, transparency, and consideration of all relevant information before making the final decision.

  4. Document the reasons for the termination, including any evidence. When documenting reasons for termination, it is crucial to provide specific, detailed, and objective explanations, supported by relevant evidence inclusive of employee responses. Utilize a consistent format, ensure all documents are dated and signed, maintain confidentiality and security, and seek legal guidance to ensure compliance with employment laws. Thorough and comprehensive documentation serves as a valuable resource for future reference, helps protect the company's interests, and provides a strong foundation in case of potential legal disputes or claims.

  5. Follow all relevant laws and regulations, including those related to employment discrimination, wrongful termination, and workplace safety. When terminating an employee, it is crucial to consider laws and regulations related to employment discrimination, wrongful termination, workplace safety, and other relevant areas. This includes understanding anti-discrimination laws like the Civil Rights Act of 1964, being aware of wrongful termination principles, reviewing employment contracts, complying with workplace safety regulations such as OSHA, being mindful of whistleblower protection laws, understanding family and medical leave laws like FMLA, and avoiding retaliation in accordance with applicable laws. Consulting with HR professionals or legal experts in your jurisdiction is recommended to ensure compliance with specific laws and regulations.

  6. Avoid publicly discussing the reasons for the termination, to protect the employee's reputation and privacy. Avoiding public discussion of termination reasons is crucial to protect employee privacy, maintain confidentiality, mitigate legal risks, preserve reputation, and foster a positive work environment. Publicly sharing termination details can violate privacy rights, lead to legal issues, disclose confidential information, create a negative workplace culture, and contravene company policies. It is best to communicate termination decisions privately and discreetly to the individuals directly involved while upholding ethical standards and demonstrating respect for employee rights and organizational integrity

  7. Provide the employee with any severance pay or other benefits they are entitled to, in accordance with company policies and applicable laws. The typical severance pay when terminating an employee can vary based on several factors, including local labor laws, employment contracts, company policies, and the employee's length of service. Severance pay is often calculated based on a specific formula, such as a certain number of weeks or months of the employee's salary for each year of service. Additionally, industry norms and practices can influence the amount of severance pay provided. It is advisable to consult with HR professionals, legal counsel, or refer to applicable laws and company policies in your jurisdiction to determine the appropriate and typical severance pay for your specific circumstances.

  8. Take steps to protect the company's confidential information, trade secrets, and other sensitive assets. To protect the company's confidential information after an employee's termination, take the following steps: review confidentiality agreements, collect company property, disable electronic access, conduct an exit interview to reiterate confidentiality obligations, monitor electronic activity, review access rights of other employees, inform relevant parties, preserve evidence if needed, regularly update policies, and seek legal advice when necessary. These actions help ensure the safeguarding of confidential information and mitigate the risk of unauthorized access or disclosure.

  9. Be respectful and professional in your interactions with the employee, and treat them with dignity throughout the process. To treat an employee with professionalism and respect during the termination process, carefully plan the meeting, communicate empathetically and honestly, actively listen to their perspective, respect confidentiality, offer support and assistance, follow proper procedures, provide a written termination letter, maintain professionalism in communication, and consider offering a reference or recommendations if appropriate. By adhering to these practices, you can ensure a respectful termination process that upholds the employee's dignity and reflects positively on the employer.

  10. Review and assess your company's policies and practices to ensure that terminations for cause are handled in a fair and legal manner. To assess the fairness and legality of your company's policies and practices, conduct a comprehensive review by examining policies, staying updated with employment laws, consulting legal counsel, considering industry best practices, evaluating consistency and non-discrimination, gathering employee feedback, conducting internal audits, providing training, establishing a grievance process, and fostering a culture of continuous improvement. This thorough assessment will help ensure that your company's policies and practices align with legal requirements, promote fairness, and reflect industry standards.

The main takeaway

Conducting a thorough assessment of your company's policies and practices is essential to ensure fairness, legality, and alignment with industry standards. By examining policies, staying updated with employment laws, consulting legal counsel, and considering employee feedback, you can foster a workplace that upholds the highest standards of fairness, compliance, and employee satisfaction. Continuous improvement, internal audits, and a robust grievance process further reinforce a culture of accountability and progress. Investing in these measures not only mitigates legal risks but also enhances your company's reputation, making it an attractive destination for top talent. Remember, a commitment to fair and legal practices is not just a moral imperative but a strategic advantage in today's competitive business landscape.

In this article, we delve into the “10 things to remember for CEO when terminating an employee for cause to protect the company from harm” chapter found in Next 10: Coach Wisdom for Entrepreneurs, Business Owners, and CEOs Wondering What Moves to Make Next, a book written by the Host and Curator of Arete Coach Podcast, Severin Sorensen, with contributions from Amelia Chatterley.

Copyright © 2023 by Arete Coach LLC. All rights reserved.


bottom of page